Skip to content

Method

Reconciliation Ecology

Terra Humana editorial teamLast updated: 4 min read

This article is also available in DeutschItaliano

Olive grove with flowering hedgerows, field margins, a pond and old trees

In brief

The practice of fostering biodiversity inside landscapes people actively use, rather than only inside protected areas set aside from them.

In the whole: Principles at work 10 Use and value diversity, 11 Use edges and value the marginal

What is reconciliation ecology?

Reconciliation ecology studies how biodiversity can be maintained and increased in the places people already use: farmland, gardens, cities, orchards, roofs, roadsides. Rather than treating nature and human activity as competitors for the same ground, it asks how a working landscape can be shaped so that many other species live there too, while it keeps doing its human job. Permaculture reaches the same conclusion from its own direction. Read literally as permanent agri culture, it asks for habitat and refuge to be built into gardens, settlements and farmland, rather than for conservation to be confined to national parks.

The term comes from the evolutionary ecologist Michael Rosenzweig, who set it out in 2003 in his book Win-Win Ecology and in a paper in the journal Oryx. His argument begins with arithmetic rather than sentiment. The relationship between habitat area and species number is well established: reduce the area of natural habitat by a given share and, over time, a comparable share of species is lost. Since protected areas cover only a small part of the planet's surface, and are unlikely to expand far enough, conservation confined to reserves cannot hold the world's diversity. Something has to happen on the rest.

Rosenzweig described classical conservation as resting on two pillars, reservation and restoration, and offered reconciliation as a third. It replaces neither. A national park still matters, and a ruined hillside still needs repair. What reconciliation adds is the recognition that the cultivated, inhabited, everyday landscape is not a lost cause but the largest unused opportunity in conservation.

The work itself is practical. Hedges and field margins that carry pollinators, ponds in farmyards, structurally varied orchards, green roofs and walls in cities, old trees left standing for the animals that need cavities: each is a modest redesign that costs the human use little and gives other species a foothold. Because both sides gain, Rosenzweig called it win-win.

Biodiversity in the land we useLearning panel: reconciliation ecology fosters biodiversity in landscapes people use. The argument begins with arithmetic: reduce the area of natural habitat by a share and, over time, a comparable share of species is lost. Protected areas cover only a small part of the planet, so something has to happen on the rest. Beside reservation and restoration, reconciliation is the third pillar of conservation; it replaces neither. Modest redesigns: hedges and field margins carry pollinators, ponds in farmyards, structurally varied orchards, old trees left standing for animals that need cavities, green roofs and walls in cities. Each costs the human use little and gives other species a foothold; both sides gain. Sa Medada is a cultural landscape of terraces and olives, to be kept in use and made richer in life at the same time. TERRAWIKI · LEARNING PANEL Biodiversity in the land we use In the same place, at the same time, by design. 1AN ARGUMENT FROM ARITHMETIC habitat species over time Reduce the area of natural habitat by a given share and,over time, a comparable share of species is lost. protected areas the rest: farmland, gardens, cities Protected areas cover only a small part. Something has to happen on the rest. 2THE THIRD PILLAR Reservation Restoration Reconciliation The third replaces neither. 3MODEST REDESIGNS 12345 1Hedges, marginscarry pollinators2Pondsin farmyards3Orchardsstructurally varied4Old treesleft standing for animals that need cavities5Green roofsand walls in cities Each costs the human use little and gives otherspecies a foothold. Both sides gain. Sa Medada is a cultural landscape of terracesand olives: keep using it and make itricher in life at the same time. Basis: Rosenzweig, Win-Win Ecology (2003) · TerraWiki: Reconciliation Ecology

How Terra Humana understands it

Reconciliation ecology names something Terra Humana was already doing, and it names it more precisely than the words we had.

The land we work on is not wilderness and has not been for a very long time. Sa Medada is a Mediterranean cultural landscape, shaped by terraces and olive cultivation. We do not intend to withdraw from it, and we do not intend to freeze it in a past condition. We intend to keep using it, to grow food and to teach on it, and at the same time to make it richer in life than it was when we arrived. That is reconciliation ecology in one sentence.

It also settles a question of language for us. Our work is active ecological restoration, and rewilding describes a different path. Yet restoration alone can suggest a return to a reference condition, which is not quite what a food forest is. Reconciliation names the part that matters most here: biodiversity and human use in the same place, at the same time, by design.

We find the underlying claim honest as well. It concedes that conservation cannot win inside reserves alone, and it puts responsibility where most of the land actually is, with the people who farm, build and live on it.

The valley of Sa Medada near Jerzu, Sardinia, with olive grove and macchia

Sa Medada

What this looks like at Sa Medada

Sa Medada is a working cultural landscape: the land register records most of it as olive grove and a small part as wooded pasture, and the slope is terraced. Project Eden does not withdraw from it. We plant into the olive grove, with nitrogen fixers and trial plantings, and the old trees remain what they are: habitat.

More about Project Eden

Frequently asked

What is reconciliation ecology?

Reconciliation ecology is the branch of ecology that asks how biodiversity can be supported in the places where people live, work and grow food, instead of only inside reserves. The ecologist Michael Rosenzweig introduced the term in 2003, arguing that there is simply not enough protected land on Earth to hold the planet's species, so conservation also has to succeed inside working landscapes. Farms, olive groves, gardens, roofs and walls all become habitat when they are designed for it.

How does it differ from restoration and rewilding?

All three aim at living, functioning ecosystems, but they differ in where they work and what happens to human use. Restoration repairs degraded land towards a reference state. Rewilding reduces human management so that natural processes take over. Reconciliation ecology keeps the human use in place and redesigns it so that other species can share the ground. It is the approach that fits a working farm or a cultivated Mediterranean landscape.

Related terms

Mentioned in

See this in practice

Permaculture principles at work here

The design principles after David Holmgren that this page puts into practice.

Sources

  • Michael L. Rosenzweig, Win-Win Ecology: How the Earth's Species Can Survive in the Midst of Human Enterprise (2003)
  • Rosenzweig, Reconciliation ecology and the future of species diversity, Oryx 37(2) 2003
  • Francis and Lorimer, Urban reconciliation ecology: the potential of living roofs and walls, Journal of Environmental Management 92(6) 2011
  • Mutillod et al., Ecological restoration and rewilding: two approaches with complementary goals?, Biological Reviews 99 (2024)
  • Bill Mollison, Permaculture: A Designers' Manual (1988)

Last updated: